ED refractorOTA only
Sky-Watcher Evostar 72ED (OTA)
- Aperture
- 72 mm (2.8")
- Focal length
- 420 mm (16.5")
- Focal ratio
- f/5.8
The most sensible entry into wide-field deep-sky imaging, provided you budget for the flattener it does not include.
Petzval refractorCamera onlyOptical tube only
A 51 mm f/4.9 Petzval astrograph with the field flattener built into the optical design — no spacers to calculate, no corrector to buy, round stars to the corners of a full frame.
A tiny, expensive, almost foolproof wide-field astrograph. You are paying for the fact that nothing about the optical train can go wrong.
Sold as an optical tube only. No mount, tripod or head is included. For imaging in particular, the mount is usually the larger part of the total cost.
Where to buy
Links open at the retailer in a new tab. We do not publish prices, because a price we recorded last month is worse than no price at all.
The same four purposes are scored for every telescope on this site, using the same weights. A telescope that is excellent for one is often poor for another — that is the point.
Visual observing
Not applicable
William Optics RedCat 51 is a camera-only instrument. There is no eyepiece position, so it cannot be used for visual observing at all — this is a property of the optical design, not a shortcoming to be scored.
Nebula imaging
8.4 / 10
Confidence: high
Fast, flat, full-frame and light enough for a tracker — the whole design points at exactly this job, with only aperture holding it back.
| Factor | Score | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Focal ratio | 5.0 | 25% |
| Corrected field | 9.5 | 20% |
| Image circle | 10.0 | 15% |
| Focal length fit | 10.0 | 15% |
| Mount demand | 10.0 | 10% |
| Imaging workfloweditorial | 9.5 | 10% |
| Valueeditorial | 6.0 | 5% |
Weighted total: 8.4. Read the full methodology.
Galaxy imaging
5.3 / 10
Confidence: high
At 250 mm focal length the image scale is far too coarse for galaxies; this is a framing problem, not a quality problem.
| Factor | Score | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Focal length fit | 0.8 | 25% |
| Resolving power | 0.7 | 20% |
| Corrected field | 9.5 | 15% |
| Optical qualityeditorial | 8.5 | 15% |
| Mount demand | 10.0 | 10% |
| Imaging workfloweditorial | 9.5 | 10% |
| Valueeditorial | 6.0 | 5% |
Weighted total: 5.3. Read the full methodology.
Planetary imaging
3.8 / 10
Confidence: high
Tiny aperture and very short focal length make planetary imaging pointless with this instrument.
| Factor | Score | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Aperture | 1.0 | 30% |
| Focal length fit | 0.0 | 25% |
| Optical qualityeditorial | 8.5 | 20% |
| Collimation & thermals | 10.0 | 10% |
| TrackingNo mount supplied — tracking quality depends entirely on the mount you pair it with. | 5.0 | 10% |
| Valueeditorial | 6.0 | 5% |
Weighted total: 3.8. Read the full methodology.
Scores are relative to every telescope on this site, not absolute quality marks. A 6.5 for galaxy imaging and a 6.5 for visual observing do not mean the same thing. How scoring works.
A Petzval puts the field-flattening elements inside the telescope rather than bolting them on behind it. The practical consequence is that the RedCat has exactly one imaging configuration — camera at 55 mm backfocus — and it is correct. There is no spacer stack to iterate on, no tilt introduced by a third-party adapter, and no corner-star troubleshooting thread to read.
For a first astrograph that removes most of the failure modes that make beginners give up.
Not possible. The RedCat has no visual back and no eyepiece position: the design places the focal plane where a sensor goes and nowhere else. Any comparison that scores it for visual observing is comparing something that does not exist.
This is the entire purpose. At 250 mm and f/4.9 with a 44 mm image circle, it frames the Veil complex, the Rho Ophiuchi region and the North America / Pelican pair with room to spare on a full-frame sensor. Star shapes hold to the corners.
The constraint is aperture. 51 mm collects roughly half the light of a 72 mm doublet, so the same signal takes about twice as long. In a light-polluted sky with a dual-band filter that difference is measured in extra nights, not extra minutes — worth understanding before buying.
250 mm gives an image scale far too coarse for galaxies. Andromeda and the Large Magellanic Cloud work as landscape subjects; nothing smaller does.
No. 51 mm resolves to about 2.3 arcseconds, which is worse than typical seeing, and the focal length would need a factor of ten of amplification to reach a usable planetary image scale.
1.6 kg and 280 mm long, with an Arca-Swiss compatible ring that mounts straight to a star tracker or a photo head. It is the only telescope here that genuinely travels in a camera bag. Nothing to collimate, nothing to cool, and the front cap doubles as a Bahtinov mask.
| Aperture | 51 mm (2") |
|---|---|
| Focal length | 250 mm (9.8") |
| Focal ratio | f/4.9 |
| Optical design | Four-element Petzval with integrated flattener |
| Type | Petzval refractor |
| Glass / mirror | FPL-53 extra-low-dispersion elements |
| Resolving power | 2.27"Calculated from aperture (Dawes limit), not a manufacturer figure. |
| Limiting magnitude | ≈ 10.5Estimated from aperture under dark skies. Real skies are usually worse. |
| Corrected image circle | 44 mm |
|---|---|
| Backfocus | 55 mm |
| Field correction built in | Yes |
| Usable visually | No — camera only |
| APS-C sensors | Supported |
| Full-frame sensors | Supported |
| Reducer | None offered |
| Corrector required | No |
| Autoguiding | Not essential |
| Mount included | No — optical tube only |
|---|---|
| Tracking | Depends on your mount |
| GoTo | Depends on your mount |
| Mounting interface | Integrated rotating tripod ring with Vixen and Arca-Swiss compatibility |
| OTA weight | 1.6 kg (3.5 lb) |
|---|---|
| Tube length | 280 mm (11") |
| Tube diameter | 90 mm |
| Longest transport dimension | 330 mm (13") |
| Brand | William Optics |
|---|---|
| Model | RedCat 51 Petzval |
| Status | Current |
| Price band | PremiumWe publish bands, not prices. Check the retailer for the current price. |
| Skill level | beginner, intermediate |
Editorial notes
We list an accessory as included only when the product record says so explicitly. If a mount, eyepiece, camera, flattener, reducer, corrector, guider or adapter is not listed above, assume it is not in the box.
ED refractorOTA only
The most sensible entry into wide-field deep-sky imaging, provided you budget for the flattener it does not include.
Apochromatic refractorOTA only
The classic do-everything four-inch apo: excellent visually, capable on nebulae with a flattener, and never the cheapest way to any single goal.